I polled for Jess. First of all cos he is extremely wellread, intelligent, has excellent taste in music and good looking, but he's also got that raw mysterious attitude which is really amazing. Luke is by far the nicest guy and he's so sweet around Lorelai and Rory, still I can't really forgive him for him and Lorelai breaking up because of him and April. So Jess wins, but Luke is right after.
Max was incredibly sweet and great as well, but way too dull for Lorelai. He was rather good looking though.
I think Logan pretty much combines Dean's sweet nature and Jess' raw attitude. Logan is really cool too, but sometimes a bit too cocky for my liking. l