Nicole Leahy Unappreciation

[Southern Lorelai]

I definately agree with Harvest Moon - Luke was just getting tired of seeing Lorelai in a different relationship. Maybe he thought that it was hs turn.

[flex151]

I absolutely think Luke's relationship with Nicole was a "I-have-nothing-better-to-do" kind of situation. I never liked her, and didn't think she was his type at all. Luke's ex-girlfriend Rachel was so spirited, as is Lorelai who we all knew he was in love with, so why he would fall for a dull as rocks, stick-up-her-butt woman like Nicole was just beyond me. I think that part of it was because he was lonely, but another reason could have been to prove to Jess that he was not lovesick over Lorelai, as Jess implied in One's Got Class and the Other One Dyes (season 3):

JESS: Hey, the girls that I like don’t give a damn about me! And unlike some other people I know, I’m not gonna sit around hoping that they change their minds and suddenly notice me.
LUKE: What’s that supposed to mean?
JESS: You fixed any neighbor’s porches lately? Or you go on a picnic or you get rooked into giving a ridiculous speech at a high school?
LUKE: Shut up.
JESS: At least I’ve got a little self-esteem.
LUKE: Shut up.
JESS: I’m not playing Golden Retriever, hoping one day she’ll turn around and fall in my arms. If she doesn’t wanna be with me, then fine.


And later on that season is when he meets Nicole, and then Jess teases him about how they were flirting, so I think he definitely influenced Luke.

By the way, who is Tyler?

That was probably just a mistake. There was Chris, Max, Alex, Jason/Digger, and then Luke. In between those she went out with that guy from her business class, Paul, and the guy she met at the auction, Peyton Sanders, but there was never a "Tyler".

[harvestmoon52]

you know, now that I think about it, I wonder if Jess ever knew that L/L were together.

And even when Lorelai told him to not propose! God Luke, I swear! 

[Stars-n-Moons]

I never liked her.  She didn't seem like Luke's type at all.  Kind of a very weird combination.

[Imy]

i agree she definitly wasn't luke's type at all!
she just didn't fit in although i did find it funny when jess was teasing luke about her!

[gilmorerock]

Raaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
perish the thought of her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[yourdoublenuts]

Stupid prolonger! She was annoying and she acted like Lorelai was a leper. Stupid Nichol

[alexisx3]

Lorelai hated when Nicole was around. And I think Nicole rubbed their relationship in her face a little. In other words, I really just didn't like Nicole.

[Cayli]

I cant stand Nicole, she was just in the way.  I LOVED the episode "Girls In BIkinis And Boys Doing The Twist" where he finds out Nicole was cheating on him.  That episode never gets old!

[gg4life07]

i dont understand why luke liked her at all. i mean she was a lawyer.

[shinkeiko]

mayb luke found her charming

[Melly721]

I hated Nicole! She was such a witch with a B (remember Lor said that once  )! I have no idea what Luke saw in her.

[gg4life07]

dont get me started with her! lorelai was never comfortable when she was around....and then nicole got all snotty at lorelai becuase thats the women that luke talked about all the time, in other words she was just plain jealous...and then it turns out she is cheating on him?!? i mean really...she was really rude and insecure. i dont know what luke saw in her...

[Miranda]

I hate the fact that she changed her hair color! First is was nice and copper, but then she turns blond! Same color as Sherry btw, when she was giving birth to Gigi and I hated it!!!! It's the exact same shade of blond  I hate both of them!!!

[SIDNEY]

lorelai was never comfortable when she was around....and then nicole got all snotty at lorelai becuase thats the women that luke talked about all the time, in other words she was just plain jealous...and then it turns out she is cheating on him?!? i mean really...she was really rude and insecure. i dont know what luke saw in her...

I don't think she was wrong to feel jealous or insecure. Luke was playing stupid to talk about another woman at his first date with Nicole. Really stupid and a little sick too. If i was Nicole i would have left him at that moment. Don't get me wrong; I do not like her. I think she was wrong to think that Lorelai was the problem and to  treat her in a negative way. She should have talked to Luke directly. Of course he'd tell her she's crazy and Lorelai is just his friend and he'd be lying but that's not the point. The point is she should have communicated with him.

Another thing, it was a teen thing to marry him just because they had a romantic day. Stupid! Then she gets divorce and then she tells him " why don't we date again?" more stupid and so unsettling of her. It didn't make sense at all. Then she cheats on him. So low of her!
Why doesn't she decide if she wants to be or not to be with him??? One day she wakes up and thinks " Oh, Luke is sooo great" and the next she is like " Awwww" . She doesn't know what she wants. She is immature and too serious and she is always  annoying.